Is Search Engine Optimisation (SEO) a scam? Apparently yes according to one prospective client I met recently. But they did accept that being high-up on Google and other search engines would be of value to their business.
SEO is basically the process of matching your website to the search terms that web users type into their search engine (Bing, Google, Yahoo et al).
Think of it as a way of creating a signpost to your business. If all the signs in the world said “go this way” we wouldn’t have a clue where we were heading. But if your business happens to be training people to scuba dive and you optimise your site for a phrase like “scuba diving school” , then there’s going to be a good chance that you will attract some highly targeted visitors who are looking for your services.
Then it’s down to the design of your website to turn these browsers into real enquiries.

High rankings can benefit your business
This is very simplistic, but the point is that SEO is not a scam because when done well it should help you get more business via your website. For us having a top ranking on Google for “Marketing Consultancy Manchester” has led to tens of thousands of pounds worth of business and has been extremely cost effective.
How much should we pay?
This is often the key question. The person we were talking to had been quoted between £250 and £1500 per month for basically the same thing. To price something correctly an SEO company should ask how many keywords, how competitive your phrases are, how complex your website is and things like that. They should also be able to show examples of terms they are successful with for other people.
Beware false examples
If your term has a geographical element (hairdressers in Liverpool for example) you should be paying towards the bottom end of the scale. If you want to be top with “cheap flights” then good luck, you will need a serious budget and a big team.
But there are terms out there which will be popular enough to make sense for you but won’t be impossible to achieve success with. If someone shows you how they got someone top with a very unusual term then it’s not really proving much by the way. You can do a lot of good work yourself by choosing the right keywords and then making some easy changes to your site and you don’t need to pay thousands for this. If you have lots of terms and your website is central to your marketing efforts, it’s worth budgeting for good SEO support.
If in doubt ask someone
We are quite happy to offer you advice on your SEO project if you feel unsure about what you’re being told. We’ll even sit in with you at meetings if you want some expert opinion. Just drop us a line.